Another Timbre TimHarrisonbre

home    CD catalogue    online projects    index of musicians    texts    orders    submissions    contact    links

antoine beuger tschitner tunings for twelve konzert minimal

at77   Berlin Series No.5                           

Antoine Beuger   ‘tschirtner tunings for twelve’     79’05”

Played by Konzert Minimal

Pierre Borel (alto saxophone), Lucio Capece (bass clarinet), Johnny Chang (viola), Catherine Lamb (viola), Hannes Lingens (accordion), Mike Majkowski (double bass), Koen Nutters (double bass), Morten J. Olsen (vibraphone), Nils Ostendorf (trumpet), Derek Shirley (double bass), Rishin Singh (trombone), Michael Thieke (clarinet)

Recorded at ausland in Berin, September 2013                                                 youtube extract

Johnny Chang

Interview with Johnny Chang and Koen Nutters

When did you set up Konzert Minimal, and why?

JC: The beginning of Konzert Minimal was near the end of 2010. At the time I’d been living in Berlin for less than two years and the opportunity to perform Wandelweiser music on a regular basis had not yet presented itself.

I discovered a Dutch bar near my flat called ‘O Tannenbaum’ (OTB) and eventually the idea of playing a concert of “Dutch experimental music” there came up. The first performance was Antoine Beuger’s “peckinpah trios” with Lucio Capece and Koen Nutters. Gradually we were able to turn it into a series of semi-regular monthly concerts of Beuger compositions, co-ordinating the timing with Koen’s visits to Berlin, as he wasn’t yet living here full time. For each concert, we invited a new musician to join in: “cantor quartets”, “kiarostami quintets”, “jankelevitch sextets” and so on, with the final (abstract) goal being “ihwe tunings for twenty”. This series became known as ‘Konzert Minimal’, and Pieter Kock of OTB gets the credit for coming up with the term.

KN: I was living in Amsterdam back in 2010, frustrated with the lack of musicians to play with, and going up and down to Berlin to play with my ensemble The Pitch. I’d met Johnny in the Wandelweiser Summer course in 2008 and we were hanging out in Berlin thinking of places where we could play some Wandelweiser music. I had played a concert with The Pitch in the O Tannenbaum bar already so, even though it’s usually a busy, noisy bar, I knew these kind of concerts that demand a bit more attention were possible there. So we invited Lucio Capece to play with us and proposed the concert of Beuger’s ‘peckinpah trios’ to the O Tannenbaum people, and they said: “Alright, let’s try it.” Somehow the busy bar atmosphere turned into a very concentrated listening situation on this Wednesday night at 21:00, so it just made sense to continue the concerts there, adding one more player each month. When we reached around 10 players, we decided to make it more of an irregular project at different locations. The ‘tschirtner tunings for 12’ is how far we have got until now and it’s been an amazing musical experience.

From the growing pool of musicians there eventually formed a core quartet of Johnny and I, Lucio Capece and Hannes Lingens. This grouping has played many concerts at different locations and lots of pieces by different Wandelweiser composers (Pisaro, Werder, Thut and Malfatti, who wrote a new piece for Johnny, Lucio, Dutch pianist Dante Boon and myself).

Why such a close focus on Antoine Beuger’s music?

KN: On a personal note, meeting Antoine and hearing his music for the first time in Amsterdam in 2007 really inspired me, and his music has been very important to me ever since. I think it’s a beautiful musical universe that interests me on a theoretical level as well as a practical one. That is: talking and thinking about the structure of his pieces is very interesting but actually playing it is a whole other experience where making decisions and not making decisions, doing and not doing, keeping an overview and just playing on your own impulses keep each other in an amazing balance.

I think that in Antoine’s music we have found a bridge between compositional strictness and improvisational responsibility to which both Johnny and I, as well as a lot of musicians from both the classical and the improvisation scene, can relate. In a way playing Antoine’s music every month in 2010 and 2011 has made our ensemble into a very sensitive musical exchange between a lot of different scenes in Berlin. It was a great way to get to know each other….

JC: I remember when I first moved to Berlin (early 2009), I didn’t know many musicians other than Lucio who showed an interest in performing Wandelweiser music. After the first concert, it occurred to us that there might be the possibility to carry on - the audience was great, so what if there were other Berlin musicians interested in listening to and playing this music? We thought perhaps we could actually continue this concept, adding one musician each concert.

It was important for me at the time, and still is now, to search for other sympathetic listeners, rather than instrumentalists who fit the profile to fill out missing frequency ranges (orchestras and improv ensembles already manage this very well without us). Antoine’s open instrumentation compositions are ideal from this perspective. Konzert Minimal has never been about collecting together a huge complement of instrumentalists who have mismatched perceptions and assumptions of listening - it may be that we won’t reach twenty in this listener-ensemble, who knows.

Can you explain how Beuger’s ‘tschirtner tunings for twelve’ works? What does the score consist of? And who was Tschirtner?

JC:  Oswald Tschirtner (1920 - 2007) was an Austrian artist who spent a large part of his life in psychiatric institutions. From 1981 he lived a very introverted life in the Artists House of the psychiatric hospital Gugging near Vienna . His works (mostly drawings or etchings) were always created in great silence and calm: he was an existential minimalist, one of the deepest.

The score is a collection of thirty pages from which any number may be selected and played. The twelve players are assigned just either one or two tones for each page. Each players may choose any octave and tuning for the given pitch(es), as well as decide when to play their tone(s).  The dynamics are soft throughout; duration long to very long. The CD represents a selection from two realisations of the first twenty pages.

Although the music is very soft, there is nonetheless a textural roughness to some of the playing, which I really like, and which perhaps reflects the background of some of the musicians’ involvement with improvised music. Do you know whether Antoine is happy for the score to be interpreted in this way, or do you think he would expect a more ‘classical’ sound?

JC: An important part of the Konzert Minimal approach is to recognise and focus on a sound which is relevant to the musicians whilst heard firmly in the context of the composer’s work. The fact is that in “tschirtner tunings” Antoine Beuger composed instrumental music, rather than music consisting of “pure” sine tones; the “roughness” you speak of reflects the intense physicality present in this music, both for the performers and the listener. The overall texture is the sum total of the instruments involved and the specific approaches which the players bring with them.

In fact, I can add that some of the roughness of sound indicates specific thinking on the part of the musicians towards the role of his/her sound in “tschirtner tunings”.  For example, a viola tone that is played with the intention of subtly colouring or shading the others from underneath, that is to say, barely audible.

This aspect of backgrounds and depth-of-field is difficult to replicate through the recording process, therefore the intention of the liner notes is to draw the listener’s attention to such possibilities in the interactions between the twelve instrumentalists, the composition and the composer.

KN: I think all the musicians in our ensemble bring their own specific instrumental sound to the table which reflects the different creative backgrounds of the different members. And I think Antoine has a very open mind about the specific ‘sound’ of the players as long as the intention of the playing is right. Johnny and I have, from the beginning, played Antoine’s pieces with a focus on the actual pitch material rather than the silences in between. Which is perhaps different from other renditions. But I think this is a very interesting and perhaps a little unexplored part of Antoine’s work: The pitch relationships and the potential for multi-layered instrumental textures.

Apart from Antoine Beuger, which other composers have Konzert Minimal focused on? And how many of the core group are also composers in your own right, as well as instrumentalists?

JC: As I mentioned earlier, Konzert Minimal began by playing the music of Beuger, but gradually the initial performances and discussions extended out to investigations of Wandelweiser aesthetics relating to listening, consideration of “space”, and the technical means which composers have used to achieve this through the work of other composers. Our framework for discussions was shaped by works such as Michael Pisaro’s “Harmony Series”, which utilises text instructions and literary references, the graphic score/spatial compositions of Stefan Thut, the wonderfully evocative “quotation” scores of Manfred Werder, and the austere richness of Radu Malfatti.

To address the second part of your question, the Konzert Minimal version of “tschirtner tunings” represents merely one moment of development and coming-together. I will say that the twelve musicians heard on the CD are all very engaging composers and/or improvisers and are well worth spending some time investigating.

KN: Besides Antoine’s music we have worked quite a bit on Michael Pisaro’s music, which presented some quite opposite musical questions and situations to us. Some of the most radical silences in O Tannenbaum occurred in Michael’s Harmony Series. Also working with Manfred Werder exposed new ways of thinking about playing (or not) to us. All in all some very different experiences and all very engaging.

I think the fact that all of the core members are composers and experienced improvisers is definitely important and perhaps even essential for playing these kind of pieces that give the players a lot of responsibility for the actual outcome. Somehow these pieces are not written for the typical orchestra player but rather for a new breed of creative musician.

All the composers you mention are members of the Wandelweiser group - as you yourself are, Johnny. But I know that Konzert Minimal have also been working with, for example, Peter Ablinger, who is from a different background and whose music often sounds very different from the stereotype of ‘Wandelweiser music’. Do you think that the ensemble is likely to widen its focus somewhat - or is it simply that the Wandelweiser group itself is now pretty diverse, and that there isn’t in fact a typical Wandelweiser style any more?

KN: I think the Wandelweiser group never really had one specific sound. But it depends on which level you are listening. I guess on a surface level all of these pieces could sound the same to someone. But I think all the composers we have worked with have a very specific way of structuring pieces and quite a unique sound - even though sometimes the material can be the same (long, quiet tones).

Besides playing pieces by Peter Ablinger and Christian Wolff, we are also starting to focus more on creating our own pieces. In our last concert, for instance, Lucio, Hannes, Johnny and I played four solo pieces (one composed by each player) at the same time. We co-ordinated the material beforehand but left a lot of space for chance interconnections. This worked really well and was very well received.

And in the next concert in Ausland (a venue in Prenzlauerberg) on the 24th of June we are playing pieces by both me and Johnny as well as works by Pisaro and Ablinger.

I think widening our focus is what we have been doing from the start and we are not likely to stop now.

JC: I would like to add that, for me, Wandelweiser music isn’t about sound or silence. Rather, it is about a heightening awareness of the functioning ear as it comes into contact with sound. To this end, and within the fuzzy parameters of personal taste, I am absolutely interested in working with composers who are committed to arriving at this aspect of music-making whilst only placing the minimum of necessary barriers between the performers/listeners and the music.

Koen Nutters


“The second time I listened to Tschirtner Tunings, I turned the volume up a bit contrary to the instructions on the sleeve and then went into the bedroom to lie down and possibly take a nap. My head was about thirty-five feet from the speakers, down a hallway and around a corner but I could hear the music, at least when it swelled a bit. I lied there not only "trying" to listen, but placing myself in the situation (impossible to do) of not having known there was music emanating from the living room, wondering how I'd perceive these sounds, whether I'd somehow redefine them as issuing from various possible sources in the street or behind our building, of wind or rain. I drifted into brief episodes of sleep, awoke, listened, drifted off again. It was quite beautiful, otherworldly.

The name "Tschirtner" didn't ring any immediate bells but when I searched, I realized I'd often seen his work, though I remain uncertain (apart from, presumably, Beuger's admiration) of any direct relationship to the composition's structure. It's performed by the gradually mutating ensemble, Konzert Minimal, here comprised of Pierre Borel (alto saxophone), Lucio Capece (bass clarinet), Johnny Chang and Cat Lamb (violas), Hannes Lingens (accordion), Mike Majkowski, Koen Nutters and Derek Shirley (double basses), Morton J. Olsen (vibraphone), Nils Ostendorf (trumpet), Rishin Singh (trombone) and Michael Thieke (clarinet). Chang and Nutters provide an excellent detailed rundown of both the group and the piece on the Another Timbre site. It runs 79 minutes, and essentially consists of emergent, long lines,, each instrumentalist choosing when his or her sound appears during a given time frame--very "simple", but allowing of a huge range of variations. Not just the pitches chosen but, as is gone into in the interview, the grain and timbre of the instruments is foregrounded, yielding many, many combinations. Sometimes, one or two instruments overlap, often more. Of course, there are silences as well. As with almost all of Beuger's music, a sense of intense calm as well as respiration and appreciation of place is achieved. When not listening from another room, I've always left the door to the balcony open, allowing the sounds to freely mix with the street, weather, etc. outside.

Not sure if there's more to say. Another beautiful offering from Beuger, lovingly realized by Konzert Minimal. That's more than enough.”

Brian Olewnick, Just Outside

“The title here refers to Austrian artist Oswald Tschirtner, who spent many years in psychiatric institutions making minimal drawings in calm silence. Part of Beuger's score (the first twenty pages) are here realized by Konzert Minimal, a twelve-member group of wind and string players. In the score only pitches, duration (long to very long) and dynamics (soft) are given.

What we have then is a series of long, quiet chords, composed of a wide variety of pitches and timbres that form tonal clouds, which arise and fall back into nothing. Occasionally one note will sound alone or hang in the air after the others have stopped. Sleeve notes recommend that the disc be played quietly, and if this advice is followed the music will blend in with whatever else is happening in your room, a slight tinting of the atmosphere, if you will. There are some interesting timbral things happening within the big chords, with some tones played sweetly and others buzzing or rasping, creating fleeting harmonics. I cannot detect any formal thematic movement here, though things move so slowly, with so much space in between tonal events, that it's hard to know for sure. One could use the word austere, but it doesn't really feel like that. More like an extremely considered way of placing collective sound in space, as though it mattered a great deal. I get the feeling of care taken, more than anything else. I've only heard a few of Beuger's pieces, but so far I like this one the most.

Incidentally, Oswald Tschirtner is also the namesake of another perhaps more well-known piece of music: Einsturzende Neubauten's Drawings Of Patient O.T.”

Jeph Jerman, Squid’s Ear

“La plupart des disques appartenant à cette série berlinoise ont pour l’instant été pour une grande part porches de l’echtzeitmuzik, mais pour le cinquième volume, une autre composante très influente de la musique berlinoise apparaît enfin : le collectif Wandelweiser. Car de nombreux musiciens s’intéressent aujourd’hui à ce collectif, en Allemagne et plus particulièrement à Berlin, il était donc nécessaire qu’au moins une réalisation d’une partition issue de ce collectif soit éditée dans cette série, même si les compositeurs issus de Wandelweiser ne résident vraiment pas majoritairement dans cette ville. The Berlin Series no. 5 est donc une version de tschirtner tunings for twelve, une partition composée en 2005 par Antoine Beuger, et réalisée ici par Konzert Minimal, un collectif de musiciens qui réunit pour cette performance(enregistrée à ausland - Berlin - en 2013) Pierre Borel au saxophone alto, Lucio Capece à la clarinette basse, Johnny Chang et Catherine Lamb au violon alto, Hannes Lingens à l’accordéon, Mike Majkowski, Derek Shirley et Koen Nutters à la contrebasse, Morten J. Olsen au vibraphone, Nils Ostendorf à la trompette, Rishin Singh au trombone, et Michael Thieke à la clarinette. Et oui, toute la fine fleur des musiques nouvelles berlinoises semble s’être réunie pour cette longue performance d’une heure et vingt minutes en somme.

Antoine Beuger est certainement le compositeur le plus influent de Wandelweiser, il est celui qui a le plus contribué à créer une sorte de marque de fabrique basée sur de longues notes tenues et du silence. Tout le collectif n’adopte pourtant pas cette méthode mais c’est ce qui est le plus retenu et le plus courant dorénavant, surtout chez ceux qui s’inspirent de Wandelweiser - notamment chez les improvisateurs. Ceci-dit, quand j’écoute les compositions de Beuger, j’ai l’impression d’entendre des variations d’une même pièce, et ce n’est pas son influence prononcée qui m’aide à me débarrasser d’une impression constante de déjà-entendu. Mais Beuger possède aussi ses particularités et n’écrit jamais deux fois la même pièce. Si les durées sont souvent indéterminées, le choix des notes l’est souvent moins, le bruit n’est pas si souvent présent - le bruit produit par les musiciens, pas celui de l’environnement - et quand au silence il est toujours là d’une manière ou d’une autre. Et pour tschirtner tunings, le principe est de réalisé une suite d’accords qui pourraient ressembler à un accordage en début de concert. Ce sont ici des accords bien particuliers, qui ne sont pas plaqués - les entrées de chaque instrumentiste sont très différées - où les notes ne semblent pas indiquées non plus, mais où la texture de l’accord est par contre bien précisée. Chaque instrument se voit attribué un mode de jeu bien précis, qu’il répète à chaque accord. L’accordéon et la trompette doivent jouer comme des sinusoïdes, le vibraphone doit jouer des notes aigues, l’alto des notes granuleuses, et les soufflants graves des notes où le souffle est présent. Les entrées, le choix des notes et de leur durée font la différence entre chaque accord. Il s’agit d’un accord répété, toujours pareil mais jamais identique, un accord qui a toujours la même texture mais jamais le même caractère selon le nombre de musiciens qui jouent simultanément, selon la durée de chaque note, selon la durée des silences précédents et suivants. Les attaques, le volume et les modes de jeux sont toujours identiques, mais le résultat n’est jamais le même, Konzert Minimal propose ici une longue suite de variations sur cette texture tendue, ténue, fine, dure et sombre.

Bien sûr, c’est long et assez austère. Mais la musique de Beuger n’est jamais très facile. Il faut toujours prendre le temps de rentrer dedans, de se laisser aborder, de s’immerger. On peut aussi parfois l’écouter de manière distraite je pense, comme une sorte de fonds harmonieux étrange, car cette musique laisse une douce atmosphère d’harmonie, malgré la tension de cette texture très vivante quand on est plus attentif. La musique de Beuger, ici et de manière générale, est belle, mais d’une beauté froide, dure et extrême. Mais c’est aussi une beauté poétique et créative.”

Julien Heraud, Imrov-Sphere

PayPal: Add Beuger / Konzert Minimal to cart